Market Structure & Trading TechnologyLiquidity ManagementBlockchain TechnologyAutomated Market MakingConcentrated Liquidity Market MakingDigital Asset MarketsDecentralized ExchangesCapital EfficiencyTokenized SecuritiesFinancial Market Innovation

The Evolution of Market Making: Combining AMM and CLMM Strategies for Smarter Liquidity Management

Frank FerraroNovember 4, 20265 min

The Evolution of Market Making: Combining AMM and CLMM Strategies for Smarter Liquidity Management By Frank Ferraro | Former NASDAQ Market Maker

Share
The Evolution of Market Making: Combining AMM and CLMM Strategies for Smarter Liquidity Management

The Evolution of Market Making: Combining AMM and CLMM Strategies for Smarter Liquidity Management rManagement

By Frank Ferraro | Former NASDAQ Market Maker


The Evolution of Market Making


Having spent decades in the securities industry, including serving as a NASDAQ market maker, I've witnessed firsthand how technology has transformed the way financial markets operate.

From traditional dealer-driven markets to electronic trading networks and algorithmic execution, one principle has remained constant: efficient markets depend on liquidity, price discovery, and disciplined inventory management.

Today, decentralized finance (DeFi) is introducing another evolution in market structure through Automated Market Makers (AMMs) and Concentrated Liquidity Market Makers (CLMMs).

While these technologies differ significantly from traditional market making, the underlying economic principles are remarkably familiar.

What I find particularly interesting is how combining traditional AMM liquidity pools with concentrated liquidity strategies can potentially create a more capital-efficient trading environment.

Understanding the Traditional AMM

An Automated Market Maker allows digital assets to trade through smart contracts and liquidity pools rather than relying on traditional order books and designated market makers.

In a conventional constant-product AMM, such as Uniswap V2, liquidity providers deposit two assets into a pool. A mathematical pricing formula determines the exchange rate as traders buy and sell.


The familiar formula is:

x × y = k

Where x and y represent the reserves of the two assets, and k is their constant product before accounting for fees and liquidity changes.

This mechanism enables continuous pricing without requiring a traditional intermediary to quote bids and offers.

However, there is an important limitation.

Liquidity is distributed across the pool's entire theoretical price curve, meaning a significant portion of the capital may support prices far removed from where trading is currently occurring.

From a market maker's perspective, this raises an important question:


How much capital is actually supporting executable liquidity near the current market price?

That is where concentrated liquidity becomes interesting.


Enter the Concentrated Liquidity Market Maker

A CLMM introduces a more targeted approach to liquidity provisioning.

Rather than allocating capital across the entire price curve, liquidity providers select specific price ranges in which their capital will be deployed.

For example, suppose a token is trading at $0.01.

A liquidity provider using a CLMM might concentrate liquidity between $0.008 and $0.012.

Within that range, the same amount of capital can provide greater trading depth than a conventional full-range AMM position, potentially reducing price impact for traders executing comparable orders.

This resembles a familiar concept from traditional market making: concentrating quoting capacity where trading activity is most likely to occur.

Of course, there is a trade-off.

If the token's price moves outside the selected range, the position becomes inactive for fee generation until the price returns to that range. The provider may also end up holding predominantly one of the two assets.

Consequently, CLMM strategies require careful attention to volatility, inventory exposure, rebalancing costs, and price-range selection.

Why Combine an AMM and a CLMM?

One of the more interesting developments in decentralized market structure is the ability to operate traditional AMM and CLMM pools alongside one another.

These mechanisms do not have to be mutually exclusive.

A conventional AMM can provide broad price coverage, while a CLMM can concentrate additional liquidity around selected trading ranges.

Consider a hypothetical token with two available liquidity pools:

Pool A: Traditional AMM

  1. Provides liquidity across the full price curve.
  2. Requires relatively little active range management.
  3. Maintains the ability to quote trades as prices move significantly.
  4. Offers a straightforward liquidity-provisioning structure.

Pool B: Concentrated Liquidity Market Maker

  1. Concentrates liquidity within defined price ranges.
  2. Can provide greater capital efficiency near the prevailing market price.
  3. Allows liquidity providers to pursue more targeted fee-generation strategies.
  4. Requires more active monitoring and risk management.

Used together, these structures offer different ways to allocate liquidity capital.

The objective is not simply to create more pools. It is to determine how liquidity should be distributed to support efficient execution under different market conditions.

There are also practical challenges. Dividing limited liquidity between pools can fragment trading depth, and arbitrage activity is needed to keep prices aligned. A poorly designed allocation may actually increase execution costs.

For that reason, a hybrid strategy should be evaluated using measurable outcomes rather than assuming that more liquidity mechanisms automatically produce a better market.


Applying Traditional Market-Making Principles


During my years as a NASDAQ market maker, managing inventory, evaluating order flow, maintaining competitive quotations, and controlling risk were essential parts of the business.

Those principles remain relevant when evaluating decentralized liquidity strategies.

1. Capital Efficiency

A market maker must understand how effectively available capital supports trading activity.

Concentrated liquidity can improve the amount of executable depth available near the market price without requiring a proportional increase in total capital.

2. Inventory Management

Traditional market makers manage long and short inventory exposure.

In a CLMM, inventory composition changes automatically as trades occur and prices move through the selected range.

Liquidity providers must understand how those changes affect their exposure to each asset.

3. Spread and Execution Quality

In traditional markets, quoted spreads and available depth influence transaction costs.

In AMM-based markets, pool liquidity, fee tiers, and trade size determine effective execution prices.

The goal is similar: provide competitive execution while appropriately compensating liquidity providers for the risks they assume.

4. Volatility and Risk Management

A narrow liquidity range may offer substantial capital efficiency during relatively stable trading conditions.

However, a sharp price movement can push the position outside its active range.

Wider ranges sacrifice some concentration in exchange for greater tolerance of price movements.

There is no universally optimal range. The appropriate strategy depends on volatility, trading activity, asset characteristics, and the liquidity provider's objectives.


A Practical Example: Managing Liquidity in an Emerging Token


Consider an emerging digital asset with limited liquidity capital.

Rather than deploying all available liquidity into a single structure, its liquidity providers could evaluate a two-part approach.

A traditional AMM pool could provide broad price coverage, while a CLMM pool could allocate capital to a narrower range where trading is expected to occur.

This could improve near-market depth and execution efficiency when the CLMM position is active.

However, the results would depend on several factors, including trading volume, price volatility, pool fees, arbitrage activity, and the allocation of liquidity between the two mechanisms.

Importantly, concentrated liquidity does not create additional capital or generate trading demand.

It changes how existing capital is deployed.

That distinction is fundamental to understanding both the opportunities and limitations of decentralized liquidity management.


The Future of Decentralized Market Structure


As decentralized trading infrastructure continues to mature, I believe the conversation will increasingly move beyond simply launching liquidity pools.

The more important questions will involve market quality.

How efficiently is liquidity deployed? What is the effective spread? How much price impact does a transaction generate? How quickly does liquidity recover following significant trading activity? And how are liquidity providers compensated for inventory and volatility risk?

These are familiar questions to anyone who has spent time in professional market making.

AMMs and CLMMs provide different technological approaches to addressing them.

Neither replaces the need for sound market structure, effective risk management, or genuine trading demand.

But together, they create opportunities to develop more sophisticated liquidity strategies.


Final Thoughts: Different Technology, Familiar Principles


Having worked through the evolution of electronic securities trading, I see decentralized liquidity mechanisms as another stage in the development of market infrastructure.

Traditional market making relied on professional dealers committing capital, managing inventory, and providing continuous quotations.

Decentralized liquidity pools automate portions of that process through mathematical pricing mechanisms and smart contracts.

Concentrated liquidity adds another dimension by allowing capital to be deployed more selectively.


The opportunity is not simply to choose between an AMM and a CLMM. It is to understand when each structure is appropriate, how they can complement one another, and whether their combined use actually improves market quality.


Technology changes. Trading mechanisms evolve.

But the fundamentals of liquidity, capital efficiency, price discovery, and risk management remain as important as ever.


About the Author

Frank Ferraro is a former NASDAQ market maker with more than 35 years of experience in the securities industry, including electronic trading, broker-dealer operations, and capital markets. He is the founder of Corporate Roadshow, Inc. and is involved in the development of New York Alt Exchange (NYALTX), a platform focused on decentralized market analytics, digital assets, and emerging blockchain-based trading infrastructure.

This article is provided for educational purposes and does not constitute investment advice or a recommendation to provide liquidity to any particular digital asset or trading pool.

#AMM#CLMM#Automated Market Maker#Concentrated Liquidity Market Maker#Market Making#Liquidity Management#Liquidity Pools#Blockchain Technology#Digital Assets#Tokenized Securities#Decentralized Exchanges#DEX#Capital Efficiency#Trading Strategies#Market Structure#Price Discovery#Liquidity Provision#Smart Contracts#Financial Technology#NYALTX

Keep exploring NYALTX

Stay in the loop with platform updates, token insights, and community spotlights.